OMITTED

What the news leaves out.

← Omitted front page

Times Square Stabbing Spree Leaves One Dead Suspect Shot by Police

10 sources · updated 2026-09-03
Left 50% Center 0% Right 50%
3 left · 0 center · 3 right

What happened

On a Monday afternoon near West 41st–42nd Streets and Seventh Avenue in Times Square, Manhattan, Pamela Cisneros, 49, of Queens, pulled two knives from a bag and stabbed a 68-year-old man from Rhode Island in the abdomen as he waited to cross the street with his wife, then about 20 seconds later stabbed Erin Piacenti, 32, of Chester, New Jersey, a Bank of America vice president, also in the abdomen. Piacenti died at a hospital; the man was treated for life-threatening injuries and later listed in stable condition. Police said the attacks appeared random and unprovoked and not terrorism-related. Officers confronted Cisneros for about four minutes, ordered her to drop the knives, and used Tasers that were ineffective; after she advanced on them and said she would rather kill them than drop the weapons, two officers shot her, and she was pronounced dead at Bellevue Hospital. NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said Cisneros had a documented mental-health history, including police encounters in 2018 and 2019 but no NYPD arrests; the department said it would investigate and later release body-worn camera footage.
Omitted — what each side leaves out

Unpacked

Left-leaning coverage is the only side to report that a justified police shooting still put other people in the line of fire. Experts quoted by the New York Times said officers opened fire "without clearing the area" and thereby risked harming passers-by. Right-leaning coverage instead reconstructs tasers failing and then the woman charging at officers with knives in hand, and it never mentions a failure to clear the street before shots were fired. Right-leaning headlines at One America News and the New York Post call the attacker "crazed." Left-leaning coverage describes an emotionally disturbed woman and a random, unprovoked attack, and does not use that word. Did any police round strike a bystander in the Times Square crowd?
Bottom line

Skip the New York Times and you never hear that experts called the Times Square shooting justified yet still a risk to passers-by, because officers fired without clearing the street.

The receipts — 6 facts one side's coverage lacks
  • Experts said officers opened fire without clearing the area and risked harming passers-by contextin New York Times · absent from right-leaning coverage
  • Piacenti had just returned from maternity leave and was a new mother individual casein New York Post, One America News · absent from left-leaning coverage
  • Cisneros's father said she had stopped going with him to her mental health appointments individual casein New York Times · absent from right-leaning coverage
  • Cisneros tried to kill herself in March 2019 by jumping in front of an E train individual casein New York Post · absent from left-leaning coverage
  • Cisneros had no prior NYPD arrest history and mental-illness encounters in 2018 and 2019 official statementin Daily Caller, Breitbart · absent from left-leaning coverage
  • Mayor Zohran Mamdani thanked NYPD officers for preventing the attack from becoming worse official statementin ABC News · absent from right-leaning coverage
The Left View
Left-leaning coverage centered on Piacenti as a Bank of America vice president and Fordham Law graduate and treated the attack as a random daylight tragedy tied to untreated mental illness. The New York Times reported that experts said the police shooting “was justified but put others at risk,” because officers “stood around a woman wielding two kitchen knives, and then opened fire without clearing the area,” risking harm to themselves or passers-by. Another Times account quoted Cisneros’s father saying he thought she had “turned a corner” after she stopped going with him to mental-health appointments. Outlets also relayed Bank of America’s condolences and noted Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s thanks to officers plus the pledged release of body-camera video.
The Right View
Right-leaning outlets framed the episode as a “grisly” or “crazed” random stabbing in “the heart” of Times Square, stressing that Piacenti was a new mother who had just celebrated a wedding anniversary and returned from maternity leave. Breitbart highlighted “shocking video” of Cisneros charging officers with two knives after saying, “I’m not dropping anything. I would rather kill both of you.” The New York Post reported her mother asking why, with “so many police,” they “didn’t they grab her by the arm” instead of shooting, while a brother said she had bipolar disorder, had been in treatment, and “never showed any aggressiveness.” Coverage emphasized an “extraordinarily dangerous situation” in a packed tourist corridor after Tasers failed.
Our Take (balanced)
The left’s strongest argument is that even a justified shooting revealed tactical and mental-health failures: Times-cited experts said officers fired without clearing a crowded area, and family accounts described bipolar disorder, a prior suicide attempt, and abandoned appointments. The right’s strongest argument is that officers faced an immediate lethal threat after a sudden double stabbing in one of the world’s busiest public spaces: video and police statements show Cisneros refusing commands, threatening to kill officers, and charging with two knives after Tasers failed, with a young mother already dead. The central unresolved tension is whether the episode primarily shows inadequate mental-health intervention and risky crowd tactics, or the limits of de-escalation when untreated illness produces sudden lethal violence in a dense public place.

10 sources

More stories

The week's bottom lines, in your inbox

One email a week: the five stories that mattered and what they actually mean. Free.