OMITTED

What the news leaves out.

← Omitted front page

Trump Tells Rally Crowd to Pretend He Is on the Ballot

2 sources · updated 2026-10-30
Left 50% Center 0% Right 50%
1 left · 0 center · 1 right

What happened

President Donald Trump, campaigning for Republican candidates in the midterm elections, has repeatedly told rally crowds to treat the contests as if he were running. At a Kansas event last month for Sen. Roger Marshall and gubernatorial challenger Ty Masterson, he said, "In this election, I'm asking you to pretend, please, that I'm on the ballot. Just pretend." During the same stretch of rallies he also made repeated remarks about other people's bodies, saying at an Oct. 12 event that after NFL coach Jon Gruden told him of Ohio Sen. Jon Husted's college football career, "I looked at his ass," later calling it a "pile of muscle," and on Oct. 25 describing supporter Nicki Minaj as having "One hell of a beautiful ass." At a later rally he said he had been "examining that man for his physical prowess," that Husted "went from being somewhat down to somewhat up in one day," and "I saved his ass."
Omitted — what each side leaves out

Unpacked

Left-leaning coverage is the only side that reports Trump's plea to "pretend I'm on the ballot." That Kansas rally line, delivered while he stumped for other Republicans, opens and closes the Guardian column. Right-leaning coverage never mentions the ask, so a reader there would not know the midterm pitch was in use. The same rally talk about other men's bodies, which both sides recount, gets opposite emphasis. Left-leaning coverage folds those comments into a list of reasons the ballot plea should fail. Right-leaning coverage leads with them as a possible way to "gas up" an embattled Republican after Trump claimed he had lifted Husted in the polls. Did Roger Marshall, Ty Masterson, or Jon Husted tell voters to pretend Trump was on the ballot?
Bottom line

Skip the Guardian and Trump's Kansas ask to "pretend I'm on the ballot" never shows up. The Daily Caller covers the same tour as a story about Husted's physique.

The Left View
Margaret Sullivan, writing in the Guardian, argues that the pretend-he-is-on-the-ballot plea "deserves to backfire," calling it an "egotistical notion" more appealing to Trump than to voters given approval ratings "in the basement" and rally conduct she and others describe as "increasingly detached from reality" — including remarks that "border on the nonsensical," closing dances to YMCA, and "unsolicited and increasingly unhinged assessments of men's bodies." She says he has been "stretching the truth," citing a PolitiFact examination that disputed his claim he had gas prices "down to the lowest level in years" (PolitiFact: $3.23 a gallon when he took office versus $4.61 by late September). She contends that second-term "widespread self-dealing," a "misguided war," social-media rants, disparagement of allies including Canada, and an "obvious plan to declare the election rigged" are working against Republicans, quoting the Wall Street Journal's Jason Riley that even "Maga die-hards and GOP allies in Congress have grown weary of his erratic behavior." Democrats including Barack Obama, she notes, are campaigning by tying GOP candidates to Trump, with Obama calling the midterms "our last best chance to at least rein in some of the foolishness of this administration." She concludes the tactic may stir a "cult-like base" but will more likely remind most voters that his "malfeasance must be rebuked and rejected."
The Right View
The Daily Caller frames the physique remarks as a new Trump "fixation" — "some serious and some not so much" — and asks whether there is "a method to the seeming madness of constantly drawing everyone's attention to Husted's butt." It highlights Trump's own claim that the commentary moved Husted "from being somewhat down to somewhat up in one day" and that he "saved his ass," and suggests that praising a "Superman-esque physique might make them, literally, more attractive to a certain voter demographic." The piece also floats that Trump, "now in his 80s," may be "trying to live vicariously through another man" or "longing for his youthful body," and treats earlier 2024 comments about Arnold Palmer as, at times, "just dudes being dudes." It does not address the request that voters pretend Trump is on the ballot.
Our Take (balanced)
The left's strongest argument is that making Trump the imagined face of down-ballot races will hurt Republicans with most voters: Sullivan points to low approval, a PolitiFact finding that gas prices rose rather than fell as he claimed, and a Wall Street Journal observation that even MAGA allies have "grown weary of his erratic behavior," concluding the "imagined association" will prompt a rebuke rather than a boost. The right-leaning account's strongest argument is narrower and tactical — that the same unconventional rally talk can move numbers, with Trump asserting Husted rose "a lot of points" in a day because of it, and the Daily Caller allowing that making a candidate "more attractive" could help some voters. The central unresolved tension is whether Trump's insistence that voters "pretend I'm on the ballot," paired with the graphic personal commentary, is a net mobilization asset for Republicans or a liability that reminds a larger electorate why they want distance from him.

2 sources

The week's bottom lines, in your inbox

One email a week: the five stories that mattered and what they actually mean. Free.