Supreme Court Declines Implicit Bias Case for Doctors
Left 50%
Center 0%
Right 50%
1 left · 0 center · 1 right
What happened
On Monday, Nov. 16, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear a challenge to a California law that requires continuing-education courses for physicians to include instruction on implicit bias, leaving a lower court ruling in place. The case was brought by ophthalmologist Azadeh Khatibi and the group Do No Harm, who argued that having to incorporate material on implicit bias in courses for doctors renewing their licenses violates the First Amendment by compelling speech. California defended the rule by saying doctors must cover the topic but are not required to endorse the concept and may openly disagree with it. In 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit had upheld the requirement by characterizing the courses as government speech, which is not subject to the same free-speech protections, and that decision now stands. Three conservative justices — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch — voted to take the case, but the four votes needed to grant review were not reached.
Sourcing check · Fully on the record · 2 articles
2 of 2 articles cite a named source for the story. It was on the record from the first report.
What these terms mean and how they're counted
- On the record · names a source 2 of 2
- On the record means the article cites a source by name for the story's main claim: a person, or an institution speaking officially, such as a company statement or a named agency's spokesperson. The opposite is an unnamed source. The count is how many of the counted articles cite at least one such source; the names are everyone named across them, each once however the articles spell it. Here: Supreme Court, Justice Clarence Thomas, Justice Samuel Alito and Justice Neil Gorsuch
- Primary evidence · cites a document or data 2 of 2
- Primary evidence means the article cites a record you could check yourself: a court filing or ruling, a dataset or report, a recording or transcript, an official statement or press release, market data. A quote is not a document. The count is how many articles cite one. Here: court action, court opinion
- Credits another outlet 0 of 2
- The article says the story comes from another outlet's reporting (“first reported by Reuters”). Those articles relay the story; they are not independent confirmation. Here: Each article presents its own reporting.
- Unnamed sources 0 of 2
- The main claim is attributed to people who are not identified: “people familiar with the matter”, “officials said”. The count is how many articles do this.
- How it developed
- When the first report landed and whether it named anyone; when the first named source and the first document appeared. Here: First report Nov 16, 15:02 UTC by The Hill, naming its source. First document in the first report, from The Hill (court action).
- Not counted 0
- Opinion, analysis and video pieces, and articles too short to assess. Every count above is out of the counted articles. An article republished under a new headline is one article.
This is about who is cited, not whether the story is true. Each source below says what it names. How we count
Omitted — what each side leaves out
Unpacked
The biggest gap is that left-leaning coverage does not really spell out the breadth of the First Amendment concerns laid out by the dissenting justices, while right-leaning coverage does. Right-leaning reporting quotes Justice Thomas warning that labeling such teaching as government speech could turn many private speakers into de facto government mouthpieces and walks through his hypotheticals involving lawyers and other licensed professionals; the left-leaning account, as presented, notes only that three conservatives wanted review and does not relay these broader stakes.
A secondary pattern is in emphasis: left-leaning coverage leads with the case falling one vote short of Supreme Court review, making the story about internal Court dynamics, while right-leaning coverage leads with Thomas ‘calling foul’ on a ruling that he says allows the state to compel speech. The former frames this mainly as a narrow certiorari decision; the latter foregrounds an alleged structural threat to free expression across many professions.
The unasked question is: how often, and in what concrete ways, has California actually enforced or monitored this implicit-bias content requirement in continuing medical education courses so far?
Bottom line
Because outlets like Fox News quote Justice Thomas’s warning that California’s approach could turn licensed professionals into government ‘mouthpieces’ while left-leaning coverage mostly notes that only three justices wanted to hear the case, readers on different sides get starkly different senses of how far-reaching this dispute over mandatory implicit-bias training might be.
The receipts — 3 facts one side's coverage lacks
- Justice Thomas argued in dissent that the Ninth Circuit’s government-speech logic could let California compel viewpoints from many licensed professionals, including keynote speakers at legal conferences, not just doctors.
- Do No Harm described implicit-bias trainings as evidence-free and vowed to keep litigating to stop the government from conscripting healthcare providers to deliver its message.
- California requires all licensed physicians to complete 50 hours of state-approved continuing education every two years, with implicit-bias instruction included as part of those hours.
The Left View
Left-leaning coverage presents the Supreme Court action as a procedural decision not to review a free-speech challenge to California's implicit-bias training requirement for doctors. It emphasizes that only three conservative justices wanted to take the case, suggesting the Court’s majority did not see an urgent need to revisit the Ninth Circuit’s approach. The focus is on California’s authority to set conditions for medical licensure and to require education on implicit bias as part of efforts to address documented health disparities. Any First Amendment discussion is framed in terms of balancing professional regulation and educational standards for physicians, rather than as a sweeping threat to free expression more broadly.
The Right View
Right-leaning coverage frames the denial as worrisome for free speech, highlighting Justice Clarence Thomas’s dissent warning that the Court is leaving the door open for states to compel private citizens to act as mouthpieces for government views. It details the plaintiffs’ argument that they are forced to include statements they disagree with in mandatory courses and notes that Dr. Khatibi believes implicit bias is not the primary driver of health disparities and is irrelevant to her topics. This coverage underscores the Ninth Circuit’s classification of the courses as government speech and relays Thomas’s contention that such a broad use of that doctrine could allow states to impose favored viewpoints on many licensed professions. It also amplifies Do No Harm’s criticism of the training as evidence-free and portrays the case as part of a wider battle over compelled ideological instruction.
Our Take (balanced)
Each side anchors its position in a different aspect of the same regulatory scheme. The strongest argument emphasized on the left is that states have long required specific subject matter in professional education as a condition of licensing, and that California’s rule still lets instructors criticize implicit bias theory while simply ensuring doctors are exposed to a topic linked to measured racial disparities in health outcomes. The strongest argument emphasized on the right is that when the state forces private instructors to deliver a defined message on a contested social concept as part of their own courses, under penalty of losing access to a professional license regime it tightly controls, that begins to look less like neutral regulation and more like compelled speech, especially if the government-speech label is used broadly. The unresolved tension is where to draw the constitutional line between a state’s power to set educational standards for licensed professions and an individual instructor’s right not to be conscripted into conveying a government-favored viewpoint.
2 sources
More stories
The week's bottom lines, in your inbox
One email a week: the five stories that mattered and what they actually mean. Free.